Add the step 5 qualitative deep-reading design and definition files

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
2026-08-17 22:38:41 +08:00
co-authored by Claude Fable 5
parent a489f077c9
commit e1355bcb70
6 changed files with 182 additions and 13 deletions
+22
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,22 @@
You are reading the complete lyrics of one song, given as
plain text.
Task: point out the problems of this song from a feminist
perspective, on this text alone.
Rules:
- Ground every problem in a verbatim quote from the lyrics;
render a line break inside a quote as " / ".
- Do not use any knowledge you may have of the song or its
performer beyond the lyrics themselves.
- The lyrics may carry more than one voice; attend to shifts
of speaker where the text indicates them.
- Do not presume that a man cannot voice "women power".
- When there is no problem, or the problems are minor,
output the single word 「無」 and nothing else.
Output: Traditional Chinese (Taiwan usage). A numbered
list, one item per problem: the statement of the problem
followed by its quotes; output nothing else. When there is
none, output 「無」 only.
+42
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,42 @@
You are consolidating the three independent reading reports
of one song into one.
Input: a JSON object:
{
"reports": ["first report", "second report", "third report"]
}
The three reports come from three mutually independent
readings, each pointing out the problems of the lyrics from a
feminist perspective with verbatim quotes; a report of 「無」
means that reading found no problem.
Task: consolidate the three reports into one problem list --
integrate, never adjudicate, never add.
Rules:
- Merge by the problem mechanism: items that point to the
same mechanism merge into one, even when their wording,
granularity, or quotes differ (for example, three reports
each quoting a different line of the same slur merge into
one item). Keep the clearest statement, keep a selection
of the distinct quotes, and judge sameness by the lyric
passages the quotes point to.
- Mark every item with its convergence: (3/3) when all three
reports raise it, (2/3) when two do.
- The main list carries only the problems raised by two or
more reports. A problem raised by a single report is not
expanded; after the list, keep it on one line:
「僅單獨提及:<one-sentence problem>、<one-sentence
problem>」.
- Never add a problem absent from every report, never drop a
problem raised by two or more reports, never rewrite the
substance of a problem, never evaluate or rank.
- When all three reports are 「無」, output 「無」 only.
Output: Traditional Chinese (Taiwan usage). A numbered
list, each item: the problem statement, its convergence mark,
and its quotes; the single-reading line at the end when there
is one; output nothing else.
+41
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,41 @@
You are inducing the recurring patterns in how the problems
appear across the consolidated reading reports of many songs.
Input: a JSON object keyed by song ID (such as "song-11"),
each value the consolidated reading report of that song; a
report of 「無」 means no problem was found for that song.
{
"song-11": "consolidated report ...",
"song-95": "無"
}
The reports come from feminist-perspective readings of each
song's lyrics; every item carries verbatim quotes and a
convergence mark, and the trailing 「僅單獨提及」 line of a
report holds the scattered findings of a single reading --
take them into account when inducing the patterns, but draw
the representative quotes from the main lists only.
Task: induce the patterns -- the recurring forms in which
the problems appear and operate -- across the reports.
Rules:
- A pattern describes how a problem works in the lyrics:
what is coupled with what, who speaks, how the mechanism
runs. It is not a category for filing problems, and not
every problem needs to belong to one; a pattern may also
cut across several kinds of problems.
- Induce the patterns from the report contents; never
introduce a problem or knowledge absent from the reports;
the number of patterns follows the material, with nothing
preset.
- For every pattern: a name, a paragraph describing the form
and how it operates, and two or three representative
quotes, each with its song ID.
- Describe and induce only; never evaluate severity, never
make recommendations.
Output: Traditional Chinese (Taiwan usage). One section per
pattern; output nothing else.